The Unseen Enemy: Insurance Fraud Costs Billions Every Year: Part II

fraud words.jpg

Part Two: How Do Companies Detect Insurance Fraud?

The insurance fraud epidemic is of serious concern to businesses, insurance providers and consumers worldwide. In Part One of this three-part series, we examined the scope of the problem, and discussed a few cases that illustrate the magnitude of insurance fraud. The question is: How can companies detect insurance fraud cases before they do irreversible damage? Working with the right experts, any company can be better protected and detect more insurance fraud.

CRI Group’s expert insurance fraud investigators have the experience and training to help business leaders identify the red flags of insurance fraud, alerting them to potential trouble. This is the first step toward moving to the next phase: investigation and resolution.

The following are just a few of the red flags that CRI Group’s investigators are trained to recognise.

Suspicious timing

Sometimes a claim is made very shortly after the inception of the policy, such as within months, weeks or even days after the insured has been enrolled. This is an obvious red flag, yet it happens more often than you’d think. Another similar tip-off to potential fraud is when the insured makes a claim soon after an increase or change in the coverage. For example, a motorist increases their auto coverage from liability to collision insurance, and soon after files a claim under their collision policy when their car is “totaled” in a one-vehicle accident. An investigator from CRI Group would certainly look deeper into the circumstances of the claim.

Frequent insurance claims and losses

We often hear that “some people are just unlucky.” That may be true, but a string of alleged bad luck that results in frequent insurance claims and payouts can signal that there is more than meets the eye. CRI Group is trained to look at the history of every claimant and uncover potential fraudulent actions. Some insurance fraudsters think they can avoid detection by filing their claims in totally different areas, like auto, health and homeowners’ insurance. Expert investigators know how to put those pieces together to look for trouble signs.

Sketchy details

Sometimes a claim for theft or fire will be for recently purchased and/or expensive property, without a lot of documentary evidence to back up the claim. That’s a red flag, along with when an insured cannot remember, or does not know, where the claimed property was acquired, or cannot provide adequate descriptions. A proper insurance fraud investigation will seek to corroborate the details of the claim, and require an examination of all supporting documentation to make sure it is complete and legitimate.

Details that are “too perfect”

On the other hand, sometimes the details surrounding a claim seem perfect – a little too perfect. CRI Group has investigated cases in which the insured had receipts and other documentation, witnesses, and duplicate photographs for everything. So what’s the problem? Things lining up a little too perfectly can tip off an investigator that things have been planned and orchestrated, and there might be fraud involved. That’s when it’s time double-check the documentation carefully, and interview witnesses to verify the facts.

Irregular documentation

We’ve discussed the importance of documentation in the investigation of a claim – whether it might be missing, or seems to be “too perfect.” But sometimes the documentation provided by the insured is irregular or questionable, which is another red flag of insurance fraud. CRI Group’s investigators look for issues with documentation such as:

  • Numbered receipts from the same source, but are dated differently or sequentially.
  • Altered documents, including receipts or invoices with dates or amounts changed.
  • The insured provides only photocopies of documents, instead of originals.  
  • Similar handwriting or signatures on different documents that are purportedly from different sources
  • Errors, such as miscalculated sales tax, or name and address misspellings, etc.
  • These are just a few of the issues that experts are trained to look for, and they know how to read the warning signs in the documentation that a layperson might overlook.

Financial difficulties

Most of us have run into financial trouble at least once or twice – overextended credit, bad investments, perhaps an ill-advised purchase. The problem is that some individuals, whether out of desperation or greed, will resort to fraud to try to straighten out such financial difficulties. CRI Group’s fraud investigators are careful to look at all aspects of a claim. Did the insured recently take a financial loss? Did they declare bankruptcy, or go through a costly divorce? These red flags become especially important when paired with one (or more) of the other red flags discussed is this article. Investigators must be vigilant, as financial pressure is one of the leading contributors to fraud.

What comes next?

Insurance fraud cases cover a wide range of schemes and crimes, and the red flags described above are just a few of the issues that insurance fraud investigation companies are trained to look for and uncover in the course of an investigation. In part three of this series, we will examine how CRI Group’s insurance fraud investigators proceed when such red flags lead to fraud, and it’s time to launch an investigation. CRI Group’s investigations cover the full range of insurance fraud cases, from health care fraud to disability and even fake death claims, always with the goal of providing the best resolution for our clients.

To learn more about CRI Group’s insurance fraud investigations, watch the video below where Ms. Naima Zohair, Assistant Manager – Global Strategy, is explaining the insurance fraud investigation services of CRI Group:



1. LexisNexis Legal Newsroom, titled “Insurance Fraud – Red Flags.”

2. Property Casualty 360, titled “10 red flags that could signal a fraudulent Auto claim.”